Comparing a software BNG with a chassis BNG on purchase price alone gets the answer wrong in both directions. The cost that matters is total cost of ownership over the life of the platform: what you buy, what you license, what you power, what you have to buy again when you grow, and what it costs to keep it patched and running. This is a checklist for building that comparison with your own numbers.
1. Hardware: what you buy on day one
A chassis BNG is bought as a chassis plus line cards, sized for the capacity you expect years from now. A software BNG runs on commodity x86, so you buy the server you need now. On BNGSOFT, a small edge site starts on an 8-core box with dual 10G; 16 cores with a dual-100G E810 covers around 100 Gbps; a 2U dual-socket with two E810s covers about 200 Gbps. Those are the same servers your team already buys, spares and supports.
2. Licensing: how the bill grows
Look at what the licence is counted against. Per-subscriber blocks tied to a specific hardware model mean paying again when you move to a bigger box, and paying for headroom you are not using yet. Count separately anything sold as an add-on: CGNAT, hierarchical QoS, lawful logging. In BNGSOFT, CGNAT is built in with no additional licence fee, and the licence is not tied to a hardware model.
3. The boxes you no longer need
A traditional design often has a BNG, a separate CGNAT appliance and sometimes a separate DDoS filter. Each one has its own purchase price, support contract, rack space, power and maintenance window. When termination, translation, shaping and filtering run in one data plane on one server, those lines in the spreadsheet go to zero rather than getting smaller.
4. Capacity: cost per subscriber, not cost per box
Divide everything by what the platform actually carries. Packets per second is the real limit: BNGSOFT forwards 50 Mpps per server with every feature enabled, which is about 110 Gbit/s at 256-byte frames and 33.6 Gbit/s at the 64-byte worst case. Your busy-hour traffic per subscriber then gives subscribers per box: on one 100G E810 at 1.5 Mbit/s per subscriber that is about 67,000. The BNG sizing calculator does this arithmetic with your numbers.
5. Power and space
Compare watts and rack units per 10,000 subscribers, measured at your busy hour. A 1RU commodity server against a multi-slot chassis is usually the largest single difference in operating cost over five years, and it compounds across every site.
6. Operations: upgrades, patches and outages
Put a cost on every maintenance window and every subscriber session dropped during one. A platform that upgrades live without dropping sessions removes that line: in BNGSOFT’s 128,000-subscriber lab run, a live upgrade caused zero session flaps. Count, too, how long a security fix takes to reach you. Software on a maintained kernel follows upstream in days; a chassis waits for the vendor’s next release train.
7. IPv4 addresses
If you are short of IPv4, the address pool is part of TCO. Port-block CGNAT lets dozens of subscribers share one public address, which turns buying addresses at market prices into a one-off configuration choice. Check your own numbers in the IPv4 savings calculator.
A simple way to compare
- List every box in the current design, with its purchase, support, power and rack cost per year.
- Add licences, including add-ons, at today’s subscriber count and at your three-year forecast.
- Add the cost of maintenance windows and of the IPv4 addresses you would otherwise buy.
- Divide the five-year total by subscribers served. Do the same for the software option, using measured packet rates with your features enabled.
Go deeper
- Compare BNG platforms: software on x86 against appliances.
- What is a vBNG? The short answer, and what makes it a real BNG.
- BNG and CGNAT for ISPs: where most operators start.
- Send us your numbers and we will size it against your own traffic.
Go deeper
- Compare BNG platforms: software on x86 against appliances.
- BNG sizing calculator: Gbps, Mpps and box count from your numbers.
- What is a vBNG?: the short answer, and what makes it a real BNG.
- Request a proof of concept: on your own hardware and traffic.


